Try Key lime pie at Pepe's Cafe

The Origins of Key Lime Pie

Despite its name, the origins of Key lime pie are a bit controversial. The tart treat's pedigree is largely traced back to Key West, though newer findings suggest that a precursor to Key lime pie was actually made with lemons in New York City a few years earlier. Regardless of where Key lime pie was invented, it is undeniably fitting to enjoy a slice while visiting Key West. (It is the official state dessert of Florida, after all.)

Where to Enjoy Key Lime Pie

Pepe's Cafe: A Historic Eatery in Key West

For some of the best Key lime pie, head to Pepe's Cafe, which happens to be the oldest eatery in the Keys. This rustic restaurant is renowned for its margaritas, mojitos, oysters, and, of course, its Key lime pie.

The Secret to Pepe's Key Lime Pie

The pie is so popular that the official recipe is available online. The secret ingredient: whipped egg whites, which make the filling especially fluffy.

See hours, menus, and more on the Pepe's Cafe website.